Skip to content
Narberth People

Norman Jefferies

1865–1933

Jersey Devil Captured!!! Alive!!!

Norman Jefferies was a theatrical producer, publicist and agent. But nothing in his career eclipsed his "Jersey Devil Hoax" of 1909.

The legend of the Jersey Devil, Mother Leeds's accursed 13th child, goes back to the 18th century. Not even Benjamin Franklin, as "Poor Richard", could resist taking up the chicanery.

For Jefferies, it was an unusual number of reported sightings of the fabled creature in January 1909 that "aroused his showman's instinct". He seized the opportunity to drum up customers for his client, the Dime Museum at 9th and Arch.

He planted cloven hoofprints in the snow throughout the region, arranged hypothesizing "experts", staged a capture in Hunting Park and announced the creature would be on view at 9th and Arch, admission to all 10 cents. Thousands reportedly crowded the museum to behold the creature. Wouldn't you?

flyer breathlessly advertises the Jersey Devil: Caught!!! And Here!!! Alive!!! Leeds Devil Captured Friday After a Terrific Struggle. Swims! Flys! Gallops! color illustration of the Dime Museum at 9th and Arch streets, rooftop flags a flutter, and banners draped over every surface advertising the exhibits within a carnival barker in tails and top hat, mouth open pointing at fantastic displays pictured behind him, a 1,148-pound woman, an orangutan in baby bonnet suckling a milk bottle and the Jersey Devil
A flyer breathlessly advertising Jefferies' scheme; Philadelphia Dime Museum in 1883, Library Company of Philadelphia; illustration by Bruce Bomberger for True magazine July 1961, story by Daniel P. Mannix

Spoiler: In the tradition of P.T. Barnum's Feejee Mermaid, the devil was a kangaroo, painted and fitted with fake wings. In some accounts, a hired boy would occasionally poke it to make the crowd jump.

Fresh off the Jersey Devil escapade, Norman and Gwendolyn Jefferies moved to Narberth between 1911 and 1914. They bought the 1883 Von Williamson house at 219 N. Narberth Avenue, maybe the third house in Edward Price's "Ladys' Book Village". Gwendolyn raised award-winning flowers in her garden, and Norman led a rather quieter existence as a promoter and agent for vaudeville acts.

When Jefferies died in 1933, the lead, and most of the ink, in his obituary belonged to the Jersey Devil. Twenty-eight years later, in 1961, he was profiled as a "Two-Legged Fox on the Midway" in True magazine, still prominently linked to the Jersey Devil.

man wearing tie, buttoned sweater and knickers lies on ground against a tree, with two women in Adirondack chairs
Norman, Gwendolyn and daughter Hulda(?) relaxing in the garden at 219 N. Narberth Ave. Victoria Donohoe Collection

An impressive collection of newspaper clippings reporting on the hoax.

The Jersey Devil on Wikipedia

Updated November 30, 2023.

U. S. Census

Census AgeRaceGenderMaritalRelationAddressImmigratedBirthplaceFather'sMother'sAs transcribedNote
192054WhiteMaleMarriedHead219 N. Narberth Ave.PennsylvaniaPennsylvaniaPennsylvaniaNorman Jefferies219 N. Narberth
193063WhiteMaleMarriedHead219 N. Narberth Ave.PennsylvaniaPennsylvaniaPennsylvaniaNorman Jeffries219 N Narberth

Census Households

Census Name Relation Age Own Race Marital Birthplace Business Trade Note
1920Norman JefferiesHead54OwnWhiteMarriedPennsylvaniaVaudevilleAgent
Gwendolyn JefferiesWife49WhiteMarriedEngland
Hulda WeihmanDaughter30WhiteSinglePennsylvania
Norman Lester JefferiesSon24WhiteMarriedPennsylvaniaVaudevilleAgent
William H JefferiesSon22WhiteDivorcedPennsylvaniaDyeingChemist
Evelyn H JefferiesDaughter-in-law22WhiteMarriedPennsylvania
Margaret NortonServant26WhiteSingleIrelandPrivate familyServant
1930Norman JefferiesHead63OwnWhiteMarriedPennsylvaniaTheatreProprietor
Gwendolyn JefferiesWife59WhiteMarriedPennsylvania

Norman Jefferies on FamilySearch (census & other records; requires free account)

Norman Jefferies on Find a Grave

Find a person

Search Help